Your best performer is also the person your team complains about most.
You know the one. The numbers are excellent. The work is sharp. And in meetings they interrupt, dismiss ideas, and treat questions like obstacles. People have started routing around them. You've stayed quiet because the results are hard to argue with.
What most managers do.
They wait. Or they bury one line about "collaboration" in a review, wedged between two paragraphs of praise, and hope it lands. It doesn't. The message the star hears is that results buy immunity. The message the rest of the team hears is louder: you will protect output over people, every time.
What actually works.
Separate the two scoreboards. Results are one. How results happen is the other. Then have the conversation in three moves.
1. Take performance off the table first. "Your work is not in question. That's not what this is about." Say it once, mean it, and don't repeat it every time they push back.
2. Describe the behaviour and its cost, specifically. Not "you can be abrasive." Instead: "In Tuesday's review you cut Priya off three times. Two people have asked to move off your project." Vague feedback gives a smart person room to argue. Specifics give them something to fix.
3. Make the standard explicit. "On this team, performance includes how the results get made. I hold you to both." Then ask what they see from their side, and listen.
A director at a professional services firm in Toronto told me she waited fourteen months to talk to her top biller about how he treated junior staff. Fourteen months, because he was the top biller. When she finally said it plainly, his response was, "I wish someone had told me a year ago." The two juniors who had already quit didn't wait that long.
Staying quiet doesn't protect your star. It sacrifices everyone around them -- and everyone around them knows it.
P.S. Have you ever waited too long to have this conversation with a top performer? Reply and tell me what finally made you act. I read every reply.
Was this useful? Forward it to a manager you know.
If someone forwarded this to you -- Subscribe free at hardconversations.co
Troy Treleaven | Hard Conversations
Dale Carnegie | Lead with Impact Program
My Calendar Link
https://app.usemotion.com/meet/0mgjn47/meeting?d=15